What Are Actors’ Rights? Performing Artist Agreements and the Transfer of Rights

In film, television and theatre productions, the artistic contribution of the actor goes beyond conveying a work to the audience: it allows the work to be interpreted in an original way and to take on new meaning. The performance delivered by the actor through voice, facial expressions, body language and interpretation is subject to legal protection under Law No. 5846 on Intellectual and Artistic Works (“FSEK”).
In particular, the ability to release audiovisual productions across different media, the spread of digital platforms and the fact that recorded performances can be commercially exploited for many years have made the scope of actors’ rights in their performances even more important.
In this context, the nature of the rights arising from the actor’s status as a performing artist, the legal consequences of transferring these rights to the producer and the limits of the rights of use granted by contract are among the key issues to be assessed by actors and producers alike.

1. The Actor’s Status as a Performing Artist and the Legal Nature of the Actor’s Rights

Under FSEK Art. 80, artists who interpret, present, narrate, sing, play or otherwise perform a work in an original manner, provided that they do not harm the moral and economic rights of the author and obtain the necessary permissions, are recognised among the holders of rights neighbouring those of the author.
Actors likewise benefit from protection as performing artists because they bring a theatrical work, a screenplay or other dramatic works to life through their artistic interpretation.
At this point, authorship must be distinguished from the status of performing artist. The author of a screenplay or theatrical text and the actor who interprets that work on stage or in front of the camera are not in the same legal position. The actor’s performance constitutes a related right that is protected independently of the author’s rights but does not extinguish the rights in the work itself.
Consequently, authors, performing artists and producers may each hold rights in the same production that derive from different legal bases.
This distinction becomes especially important where the actor’s performance is recorded, reproduced, published or reused for different purposes.

2. Economic and Moral Rights of the Performing Artist

FSEK Art. 80 grants performing artists both economic and moral rights in their performances.
Economic rights cover the powers relating to the commercial exploitation of the actor’s performance. In this context, forms of use such as the fixation of the performance and the reproduction, distribution, public performance and communication to the public of the fixed performance are subject to the performing artist’s power to authorise or prohibit, under the conditions laid down by law.
For example, the use of an actor’s performance in a television series across different broadcasting media, or the recording of a theatre performance and making it available on a digital platform, are forms of use that must be assessed in light of the performing artist’s economic rights.
However, it cannot be said that each new use of a performance automatically constitutes a separate infringement. The lawfulness of a use must be determined according to the scope of the permission given or the transfer of rights made by the actor.
Moral rights, on the other hand, aim to protect the relationship between the actor’s performance and the actor’s personality and artistic reputation.
Under FSEK Art. 80/1-A(1), even after having transferred their economic rights, performing artists may, under the conditions set out in the law, demand to be identified as the owner of their performance and demand the prevention of any distortion or mutilation of the performance that could damage its reputation.
In particular, editing an actor’s performance out of context so as to create a different meaning, or using it in a way that could damage the actor’s artistic reputation, is significant from the standpoint of protecting moral rights.
Furthermore, the use of an actor’s image, voice and other elements that identify the actor’s personality may, depending on the circumstances of the case, also bring into play the provisions on personality rights and the protection of personal data.

3. Transfer of Economic Rights in Acting Agreements

In practice, the transfer to the producer of the actor’s economic rights in the performance is usually governed by acting agreements.
Under FSEK Art. 80, performing artists may transfer the rights provided for by law to the producer by contract in return for appropriate consideration. However, this does not mean that all of the actor’s rights in the performance pass to the producer without any limitation.
In determining the scope of a transfer of rights, the content of the contract, the relevant statutory provisions and the nature of the powers transferred must be assessed together.
It is therefore important that acting agreements clearly specify which rights of use are transferred. In particular, the medium of use, the term, the geographical scope, the power to authorise use by third parties and the consideration payable for the use are among the essential elements of the contract.
Broadly worded clauses frequently encountered in practice, such as “use in all media, indefinitely, without limitation and irrevocably”, may give rise to problems of interpretation regarding the limits of the transfer of rights.
FSEK Art. 52 provides that contracts and dispositions concerning economic rights must be in writing and that the rights forming the subject of the contract must be specified individually. The application of this provision to the transfer of performing artists’ related rights, however, must be assessed together with the relevant special provisions.
Accordingly, a general statement of transfer of rights in a contract should not be taken as automatically and indisputably covering all future forms of use of the actor’s performance.
In particular, the later emergence of forms of use that were not foreseen when the contract was concluded makes determining the rights and obligations of the parties even more important.

4. Reruns and Use on Digital Platforms

The renewed commercial exploitation of an actor’s performance after its first showing or broadcast is one of the most widely debated areas of performing artists’ rights in practice.
The rerun of a television series on different channels, its release on digital platforms or its licensing for broadcast in other countries enables the same performance to generate economic value through different forms of use.
However, whether the actor can claim additional remuneration on account of these uses cannot be determined solely on the basis that a rerun has taken place.
Here, the first step is to examine which rights relating to the performance the actor transferred to the producer and whether the use in question falls within the scope of that transfer.
For example, permission given only for a specific television broadcast and the transfer of a broad right of use that also covers making the performance available on various digital platforms may not produce the same legal consequences.
In addition, whether the payments to be made to the actor were set solely in return for the initial performance or also cover subsequent uses is important for the contractual assessment.
Therefore, in disputes arising from reruns, the key issue is not so much whether each rerun gives rise to a separate claim for remuneration, but whether the use in question remains within the limits of the permission previously given or the transfer of rights previously made.
With the development of digital broadcasting, the fact that the same production may remain accessible through different platforms for many years has made more apparent the need for rights of use and financial consideration to be clearly regulated in acting agreements.

5. Infringement of Performing Artists’ Rights and Legal Protection

Where an actor’s performance is used beyond the powers granted by contract, or the actor’s statutory rights are infringed, different legal remedies may come into play depending on the nature of the infringement.
At this point, contractual remuneration claims must be distinguished from claims arising from infringement of the performing artist’s related rights.
For example, failure to pay the actor the fee agreed in the contract is, as a rule, treated as a breach of contractual obligation, whereas the use of the actor’s performance outside the permitted scope may amount to an infringement of a related right.
Where an infringement has occurred, the remedies provided for under the FSEK and, depending on the circumstances of the case, claims based on the general provisions may come into play.
In this context, prevention of the infringement, its cessation, a claim for damages where the conditions are met, or collection of receivables arising from the contract may be at issue.
However, in determining the available legal remedies, the legal basis of the claim and the right allegedly infringed must be correctly identified.
In particular, establishing on which media, on which dates and for which purposes the actor’s performance was used is important for interpreting the scope of the contract and demonstrating infringement in potential disputes.

Conclusion

The rights arising from an actor’s status as a performing artist confer certain powers over the commercial exploitation of the artistic performance, while also protecting the personal and artistic bond that the actor forms with the performance.
Nevertheless, the extent to which the actor’s statutory rights can be protected in practice depends largely on the content of the contractual relationship established with the producer.
Particularly in film, television and digital broadcasting, the fact that the economic life of a production can extend far beyond the time the actor actually spent working makes it necessary to clearly determine, at the contract formation stage, the powers and financial consideration relating to subsequent uses of the performance.
In this context, it is important to treat acting agreements not only as a service relationship for the delivery of the performance, but also as a legal instrument governing the use of performing artists’ rights.
Striking a balance between the actor’s artistic labour and the producer’s economic and organisational interests depends on the scope of the transfer of rights being set out in a manner that is clear, foreseeable and consistent with the parties’ mutual obligations.

Legal Sources

Law No. 5846 on Intellectual and Artistic Works (Fikir ve Sanat Eserleri Kanunu), in particular Art. 52 and Art. 80.
Regulation on Rights Neighbouring the Rights of Authors (Eser Sahibinin Haklarına Komşu Haklar Yönetmeliği).
Post Tags :
Share this post :